Curry murder

Singapore Infopedia


The "curry murder" was a high-profile murder case in 1984 that supposedly involved the perpetrators covering up the killing by chopping the victim Ayakanno Marimuthu's (given as Marithamuthu in some sources) body into pieces and cooking them in curry. In March 1987, six suspects, including Marimuthu's wife Nagaratha Vally Ramiah and her relatives were charged with murder, but given a discharge not amounting to an acquittal as no remains or evidence of the killing were ever found.1

Investigation of the murder
On 9 January 1987, an informer notified Detective G. Alagamalai that in 1984, a man by the name of Ayakanno Marimuthu had been murdered and his body chopped up into pieces and cooked in curry. Marimuthu was a caretaker at the Public Utilities Board holiday chalets in Changi. Alagamalai was initially disgusted and sceptical, but brought up the story to his superiors in the Criminal Investigation Department (CID). The senior officers in the CID were equally sceptical of the informer's story, but instructed Alagamalai to conduct inquiries into the case.2

Alagamalai soon found a missing-persons report on Marimuthu lodged by his wife Nagaratha Vally Ramiah on 18 December 1984 at the Joo Chiat police station. In the report, Ramiah stated that her husband had not returned from a trip to Genting Highlands in Malaysia having left Singapore on 12 December. Police found no cause for suspicion of foul play and recorded Marimuthu as a missing person. Months later, Ramiah was employed as a caretaker at the Foochow Methodist Church on Race Course Road.3

With his informant's story given credibility by Marimuthu's missing-persons report, Alagamalai pressed on with his investigation. Over the course of a two-month investigation, he spoke to about 30 people and gathered background information on a number of suspects, one of whom was a mutton butcher.4

On 23 March 1987, the CID's Special Investigation Section conducted an operation to bring in the suspects. From 2 am that day, five police teams raided different locations simultaneously, including a flat in Jurong East, a caretaker's quarters on Netheravon Road and the Orchard Road Presbyterian Church. By 9 am, a total of eight suspects were rounded up. They were Marimuthu’s widow Ramiah, his mother-in-law Kamachi Krishnasamy, Ramiah’s three brothers Rathakrishnana Ramayah, Shanmugam Chandra and Balakrishna Ramiah and their wives.5

Balakrishna Ramiah was a butcher at a mutton stall at Commonwealth Avenue market, while his brothers Ramayah and Chandra were caretakers at the Ministry of Finance's holiday chalets on Netheravon Road and the Orchard Road Presbyterian Church respectively. Krishnasamy was a housewife, while Mary Manuee, Ramiah's sister-in-law, was a factory worker.

The suspects initially denied any knowledge of Marimuthu's murder, until 25 March 1987 when investigators established from one of them the details of the case. Details of the gruesome murder soon emerged. According to the suspect’s revelation, Marimuthu was brought to the caretaker's quarters of the Presbyterian Church by the three brothers on the afternoon of 12 December 1984.7

On that night, it was said that Marimuthu was bludgeoned with an iron rod in the kitchen of the quarters and his body chopped up and cooked with chilli powder, spices and rice in a large aluminium pot of the type often used in Indian restaurants to cook nasi briyani, a popular rice dish served with either chicken, mutton or fish. The remains, including cracked pieces of skull and bones, were placed into black plastic bags and disposed of in several roadside rubbish bins.8

Then-director of the CID, Assistant Commissioner Jagjit Singh, described the case as "one of the most unusual and bizarre murder cases handled and solved by [the] police – unusual because the remains of the body have never been found and the deceased had not even been reported to have been murdered; bizarre because of the manner in which the body was disposed of".

A newspaper report of the murder in March 1987 described the victim Marimuthu as often being drunk and violent, and physically abusive towards his wife Ramiah. A spokesman for the Orchard Road Presbyterian Church also said the duo were a hardworking couple, and that Marimuthu possessed a hot temper but would apologise after calming down.10 

The trial and subsequent events

On 27 March 1987, Ramiah and her three brothers Balakrishna, Ramayah and Chandra were charged with the murder of Marimuthu, while her mother Krishnasamy and sister-in-law Manuee were charged the following day with abetting the murder. The six were brought to court on 6 June 1987.11

During a 12-minute hearing, the prosecution said there was insufficient evidence to proceed against them as neither the remains of the victim's body, the murder weapon nor the cooking pot were found. District Judge Zainol Abeedin gave the six a discharge not amounting to an acquittal, which meant that they could be charged again for the same offence. Deputy Public Prosecutor Ang Sin Teck added that police investigations would continue with the intention of future charges. After the hearing, the six were taken back into custody by the CID.12

Ramiah, Krishnasamy and Manuee were not rearrested, but the three brothers were detained at Changi Prison from 22 June 1987 under the Criminal Law (Temporary Provisions) Act. After a number of applications for habeas corpus (a writ or court order) were denied, a legal challenge to their detention in March 1991 succeeded, and they were released unconditionally on 21 June 1991.13  

Television dramatisation and defamation case

The "curry murder" was adapted for television as part of a 20-episode drama serial featuring five true crime stories. The Mandarin serial titled Doctor Justice was produced by the Television Corporation of Singapore (TCS; now Mediacorp) and aired on Channel 8 in 1995.14

Following the coverage of Doctor Justice in an article in The Straits Times, the six former suspects sought damages by asserting that the newspaper had defamed them through misleading language that placed the responsibility of the murder on them. The court ruled in favour of The Straits Times, stating that only facts were dealt with in the article. It also dismissed the suit against TCS, which was involved in the case as a second defendant.15

Alex Chow & Alvin Chua

1. “Five Months of Digging into Caretaker's Murder,” Straits Times, 7 June 1987, 2; “Judge Frees Six Charged in Curry Murder Case,” Straits Times, 7 June 1987, 1. (From NewspaperSG)
2. Lai Yew Kong, et al., “Diary of a Bizarre Killing,” Straits Times, 27 March 1987, 11. (From NewspaperSG)
3. Lai, et al., “Diary of a Bizarre Killing.”
4. Lai, et al., “Diary of a Bizarre Killing.”
5. Lai, et al., “
Diary of a Bizarre Killing”; “Five Months of Digging into Caretaker's Murder.”
6. “Five Months of Digging into Caretaker's Murder.”
7. “Curry Murder Horror,” Straits Times, 27 March 1987, 1. (From NewspaperSG)
8. “Curry Murder Horror”; Lai, et al., “Diary of a Bizarre Killing.”
9. “Curry Murder Horror”; Lai, et al., “Diary of a Bizarre Killing.”
10. “Curry Murder Horror.”
11. “Five Months of Digging into Caretaker's Murder”; “Judge Frees Six Charged in Curry Murder Case.”
12. “Judge Frees Six Charged in Curry Murder Case.”
13. Brendan Pereira, “Three Held since 1987 Freed,” Straits Times, 22 June 1991, 1; “‘Curry Murder’ Case Brothers Challenge Detention,” Straits Times, 10 March 1991, 11; “Three Drop Action against Government for Wrongful Detention,” Straits Times, 21 July 1991, 15. (From NewspaperSG)
14. Chin Soo Fang, “Curry Murder Case to Be in New TCS Serial,” Straits Times, 6 May 1995, 16. (From NewspaperSG)
15. Brendan Pereira, “‘Curry Murder’ Defamation Case Dismissed,” Straits Times, 18 April 1996, 34. (From NewspaperSG)

The information in this article is valid as at 23 October 2014 and correct as far as we are able to ascertain from our sources. It is not intended to be an exhaustive or complete history on the subject. Please contact the Library for further reading materials on the topic.

Rights Statement

The information on this page and any images that appear here may be used for private research and study purposes only. They may not be copied, altered or amended in any way without first gaining the permission of the copyright holder.

More to Explore

Singapore’s first liver transplant


Singapore’s first liver transplant was successfully performed on 25-year-old Surinder Kaur on 29 September 1990. The transplant was performed by a team of four surgeons and two anaesthetists from the National University Hospital (NUH). The team was led by Susan Lim, the second female doctor in the world to perform...

Singapore Prison Service


The Singapore Prison Service (SPS) is a government agency under the Ministry of Home Affairs. Headquartered at 407 Upper Changi Road North, it administers 14 institutions in Singapore. In addition to ensuring the secure custody of inmates, the prison service works to help them turn over a new leaf and...

Maintenance of Parents Act


The Maintenance of Parents Act provides for Singapore residents aged 60 years old and above who are unable to subsist on their own, to claim maintenance from their children who are capable of supporting him but are not doing so. Parents can sue their children for lack of maintenance, in...

Opium Treatment Centre


The Opium Treatment Centre opened in February 1955 on St. John’s Island for the treatment and rehabilitation of opium addicts. The centre was the colonial government’s first attempt at treating addicts; prior to this, opium addicts were charged in court and sent to prison....

Six-digit postal code system


The six-digit postal code system was introduced in Singapore in 1995. It was adopted by Singapore Post (SingPost) with the aim of facilitating the automation of mail processing, in particular the mail-sorting system. ...

Beauty World


Opened in 1947, Beauty World was a popular market and shopping destination in Singapore during the 1960s. Located at the junction between Upper Bukit Timah Road and Jalan Jurong Kechil, the market comprised over a hundred stalls that sold all kinds of daily necessities such as fresh produce, household items,...

Singapore Cord Blood Bank


The Singapore Cord Blood Bank (SCBB) was officially opened by then Minister for Health Khaw Boon Wan on 28 September 2005. The accredited public cord blood bank was set up in response to the demand from paediatricians and haematologists to increase the number of cord blood units available for unrelated...



Getai (??), which literally means “song stage” in Chinese, is believed to have originated during the Japanese Occupation at the New World Amusement Park. It became a popular form of mass entertainment in the 1950s with getai established at various amusement parks. Today, getai is mainly staged during the Hungry...

First Road Courtesy Campaign


The Road Courtesy Campaign launched by then Deputy Prime Minister Toh Chin Chye on 10 September 1966 is the first national campaign to try and instil more awareness of road safety in all road users. It marked the start of a sustained effort in Singapore to bring down the number...

Stanley Warren and the Changi Murals


Stanley Warren (b. 1917, London, England–d. 20 February 1992, Bridport, England), a bombardier with the 135th Field Regiment, Royal Artillery, was known as the painter of the murals in St Luke’s Chapel of the Roberts Barracks in Changi while interned as a prisoner-of-war (POW). Based on selected texts from the...