Beta BETA

Volume 5 Issue 1: Tariffs

Read to be SURE

tariff
  • Share

Do Tariffs Help or Hurt?

A tariff is a tax imposed by one country on the goods and services imported from another country. For example, if Country A imposes a 10% tariff on bicycles coming from Country B, the importer in Country A must pay an additional $10 for every $100 of the bicycle’s value. While importers often pass these costs on to consumers through higher prices, they may also absorb some of the tariff costs themselves.

Tariffs date back to ancient times, and have been used all throughout history. However, the use of tariffs have gradually declined since the 18th century, and especially after World War II, as the globalised world moved towards free trade. Yet, many countries still use tariffs today. Tariffs can be a double-edged sword. Whether they help or hurt depends on who you’re asking, what goods are involved, and the broader economic context. So, what are the current arguments for and against tariffs?

  • Do Tariffs Help or Hurt?

    Tariffs can be harmful

    Tariffs can be beneficial

    Tariffs can hurt the domestic market.

    Tariffs may lead to higher prices of imported goods and less variety in the long-run . Low-income households are generally hit the hardest, as they spend a higher proportion of their income on necessities.

    Domestic industries may also become less efficient and innovative as they would not need to compete with overseas firms.

    Moreover, other industries which depend on imported goods as inputs will likely suffer from higher costs, which might hamper growth and lead to job losses. (E.g. car producers rely on imported steel as an input).

    Tariffs can be used to protect certain domestic industries in the short-term.

    Tariffs can be a temporary tool to protect infant industries from overseas competition so that they can develop and become efficient. Some attribute the economic development of Asian countries like South Korea to this strategy.

    However, it can be difficult to judge which industries are worth protecting to begin with. Moreover, such tariffs can be tricky to remove later.

    Tariffs often lead to lower economic efficiency globally.

    Tariffs interfere with the principle of comparative advantage, where efficiency is maximised as each country focuses on what they are best at producing.

    • Country A produces wheat at less cost than Country B
    • Country B produces apples at less cost than Country A
    • It is more economically efficient for A to produce wheat, and B to produce apples, and for both to trade with each other.
    • Conversely, if they were to impose tariffs on each other and try to produce both wheat and apples, there would be less wheat and apples produced in total.

    Tariffs can help in safeguarding national interests and autonomy.

    Tariffs may be needed to counteract unfair practices like dumping. This refers to selling products at an artificially low price to gain market share.

    Outsourcing the production of certain goods or services to other countries might also pose a risk to national security. Particularly when trade relationships are unequal, dependence on trading partners makes a country vulnerable to external pressures. This is especially so if it is for key industries, like oil or steel.

     

    In conclusion, tariffs generally lead to lower efficiency and higher costs domestically and globally. This would get passed down to consumers in the form of higher prices. Higher prices, in turn, will reduce the aggregate demand for products that are subjected to the tariffs. Singapore, as a small country with little natural resources, has consistently favoured a free and open economy with minimal tariffs.

    Nonetheless, there are some scenarios where tariffs may be beneficial, and many of the free-market countries still have certain tariffs in place. Yet imposing tariffs or raising existing ones can trigger retaliatory measures that escalate into a trade war among countries. This may have knock-on effects on other countries, increasing geopolitical instability.

    At the same time, it is important to note that tariffs are not the only tool to reduce trade with another country. Import quotas and subsidies can also have a large effect on trade, even though they may get less attention in the news.

    After reading about tariffs and their possible effects, what's your take? Take a moment to share your views in our survey: https://go.gov.sg/rtbs-survey-tariffs

  • Recommended Resources

    Videos

    Asst Prof Goh Jing Rong on potential impact of Trump's tariffs on Singapore's economy

    CNA, “Asst Prof Goh Jing Rong on potential impact of Trump's tariffs on Singapore's economy,” YouTube, 3 February 2025, video, 07:57.

    International Trade Explained

    CFR Education, “International Trade Explained,” YouTube, 18 June 2019, video, 06:41.

    Podcast

    Fixing Global Trade: Why Tariffs and Trade Wars Aren't Enough

    “Fixing Global Trade: Why Tariffs and Trade Wars Aren’t Enough”. The World Unpacked. Produced by the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 12 December 2024. Podcast, 27:25 

    Websites

    What are tariffs, and why are they rising?

    Elijah Asdourian and David Wessel. “What are tariffs, and why are they rising?” 1 July 2024.

    How do tariffs work – and do they work?

    John Letzing. “How do tariffs work – and do they work?” World Economic Forum, 4 Feb 2025.

     

    eBooks



    free trade under fire

    Irwin, Douglas A. Free Trade Under Fire. 5th ed. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2020

    Retrieved from OverDrive. (myLibrary username is required to access the eBook).


    globalisation and its disconents

    Stiglitz, J. E. Globalization and its discontents revisited: Anti-globalization in the era of Trump. New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 2017

    Retrieved from OverDrive. (myLibrary username is required to access the eBook).


     

    Erixon, Fredrik, and Björn Weigel. Trade Is Not a Four-Letter Word: The Globalization Debate. New York: St. Martin's Press, 2020.

    Retrieved from OverDrive. (myLibrary username is required to access the eBook).